Why are there so many bugs again? 😣
Thank you to Happy Fish for the curator copy.
This is nonetheless an impartial review.
Where is the Steam “neutral” button when you need it? It honestly hurts putting this one on the not-recommended side, especially coming from Happy Fish. There’s something genuinely inventive here, but it’s buried under technical issues that turn a clever idea into a bit of a clicking fest. There are 8 levels, each with around 16 to 30-something cats to find. A good chunk are blended into the pixel art, a bit like in Cats in Pixels by Louisselle, while many others are camouflaged behind interactive elements or small puzzles. The pixel art itself is pretty nice too, even if a few characters feel like they wandered in from a different game. There’s a decent amount of content for the price, sound sliders are there, you can reset levels anytime, and the save system behaves properly. Achievements are clean, easy to understand, and follow normal progression, which is always appreciated.
Now... the hint system. It technically works, but also kind of doesn’t. It highlights where a cat should be, but if that cat is locked behind an interaction you haven’t triggered yet, the hint just sits there mocking you. It’ll also keep pointing to the same spot until that specific cat is found, and it'll be spent uselessly if the cat is off-screen. So yes, hints can be spent for absolutely nothing and need 2-3 recharges until you find the right zone with the missing cat.
The interactions themselves are where things really go haywire. Clicking near previously used items can retrigger animations over and over, sometimes stacking in weird ways. Cats and objects can appear over the very obstacles that are supposed to hide them, which completely breaks the illusion. One sub-area even counts every click with a sound, piling them up into a chaotic mess. It’s not game-breaking in a “can’t finish” way, but it constantly disrupts the experience to the point that I'm more relieved than relaxed after completing all levels. Also, worth noting that the cats that aren't linked to interactive elements often end up being just right there, in plain sight, which removes any purpose to “Find Cats”. Add the lack of zoom, and the whole thing starts feeling less like a thoughtful search and more like rapid-fire clicking until something happens especially without useful hints.
I really wanted to love this one. The ideas are there, and you can see the potential for something special in the hidden cat space. But between the buggy interactions, awkward hints, and inconsistent hiding, it turns into a frustrating experience way too quickly. I know Happy Fish can do better, they’ve already proven it with Find Cats 1, 2, 3 and 4, and I really hope those ideas get the polish they deserve next time.
For more reviews like this one, please check out Ele's Little Recommendation Corner!
For reviews covering all types of indies, recent and old, don't hesitate to drop by IndieGems!